maybe it's just me, but ...
- FFJim
- HoF 2007 & CotY

- Posts: 3024
- Joined: Tue Aug 24, 2004 11:19 am
- Location: Michigan
maybe it's just me, but ...
I think it is deplorable that a Funatic would outbid fellow Funatics on eBay, wobble dance about how great the score will look on the shelf, and then 3 days later PM one of the bidders and offer it at $750 -- a $230 profit.
-
mustangtoys
i had 2 different emails of $650 and & $750.i thought i was just gonna be nice to email funkofanjim because i want him to have an awsome collection. i had no intentions of selling but with these crazy prices people would by it off me for i said i can resist because i would get 2 48's.(wow!) i won't sell it at all whatsoever now.i am gonna keep it.sorry i affended you Jim.
:wi
:wi- Otto13
- Hall of Fame Class of 2005

- Posts: 1908
- Joined: Thu Apr 17, 2003 1:30 am
In the old days...
You score a great piece and you work a deal in favor of someone like FFJim (he's obviously a whale- Vegas term) and see what happens later. Because of the deals I have put forth...I have only paid for one of my 48's...(I am still missing the Lefty Lime). The rest I either got at a gathering or FREE!
No offense but if anyone is looking to "help me" while making a profit...I think the US Government fulfills that role in my life thank you very much!
You score a great piece and you work a deal in favor of someone like FFJim (he's obviously a whale- Vegas term) and see what happens later. Because of the deals I have put forth...I have only paid for one of my 48's...(I am still missing the Lefty Lime). The rest I either got at a gathering or FREE!
No offense but if anyone is looking to "help me" while making a profit...I think the US Government fulfills that role in my life thank you very much!
New York ....................................Paris...............................Chula Vista
- cliffd64
- Hall of Fame Class of 2006

- Posts: 2327
- Joined: Sat Apr 26, 2003 4:27 pm
- Location: Statesville, NC
Otto13 wrote:No offense but if anyone is looking to "help me" while making a profit...I think the US Government fulfills that role in my life thank you very much!
I WISH the US Government actually made a profit on ANY of the taxes it collects... More often than not, it loses all the money it collects and THEN SOME!!!



-
Funatic Bear
- Collector of the Month

- Posts: 1584
- Joined: Tue Jun 01, 2004 2:32 pm
- RDK
- Hall of Fame Class of 2009

- Posts: 2250
- Joined: Mon Apr 28, 2003 5:54 pm
- Location: Los Angeles
It seems like unfortunate timing and human nature is the key problem here. There's no reason the high bidder shouldn't get this piece, but Mustang's offer to Jim could be perceived as profiteering on its surface. If one's willing to pay over $500 for a chunk of plastic, one presumably wants it pretty badly. If someone's emailing him with higher offers after the auction closes, then I'd ask why they didn't bid on it directly. But if there was a legit offer of $750, why would Mustang be obliged to offer it to Jim for less?
I'll dare to say, too, that Jim has shown himself to have relatively deep pockets and a lack of patience when it comes to acquiring rare wobblers. Nothing wrong with that, of course - I should be so lucky! - but it does set him up as a bit of a mark when it comes to a potential seller offering him a rare piece. For 48s and less, it's obviously a seller's market, and situations like this should be expected. Unfortunate, perhaps, but nevertheless true.
I'll dare to say, too, that Jim has shown himself to have relatively deep pockets and a lack of patience when it comes to acquiring rare wobblers. Nothing wrong with that, of course - I should be so lucky! - but it does set him up as a bit of a mark when it comes to a potential seller offering him a rare piece. For 48s and less, it's obviously a seller's market, and situations like this should be expected. Unfortunate, perhaps, but nevertheless true.
Ray
- Otto13
- Hall of Fame Class of 2005

- Posts: 1908
- Joined: Thu Apr 17, 2003 1:30 am
If you are buying and selling pieces for profit...then the old fish in a barrel argument is all that I'll offer. If you really want a piece...money isn't an issue. If money is an issue then you are in a hobby that you can't afford. If you are using more than disposable income...take drugs instead. But to out bid a collector and then say that someone else is offering more but I wanted to offer it to you first...that selling snake oil.
I think Jim did the right thing in brining this to everyone's attention.
I don't think someone with the $$$ to spend on pieces should be told they have a lack of patience...
I don't get it...why bid on something and then turn around and sell it and call yourself a collector? Go to the gatherings, pay the $50 and then sell your piece for maximum $$$...as a collector of course!
I think Jim did the right thing in brining this to everyone's attention.
I don't think someone with the $$$ to spend on pieces should be told they have a lack of patience...
I don't get it...why bid on something and then turn around and sell it and call yourself a collector? Go to the gatherings, pay the $50 and then sell your piece for maximum $$$...as a collector of course!
New York ....................................Paris...............................Chula Vista
-
Funatic Bear
- Collector of the Month

- Posts: 1584
- Joined: Tue Jun 01, 2004 2:32 pm
What I do find amusing for most part, is that I've never known a 9 years old who aquiring expensive pieces in order make profits in this kind of business. I am at awe. I know it's the 21st century and kids today aren't what kids used to be 30 years ago, but still... I guess MustangToy will be a successful salesman in the future.
But I agree with Otto, that is just not ethical nor cool for someone who supposed to be a hobby collector. Of course, some people realize after spending a lot of money, that they are out money.
But I agree with Otto, that is just not ethical nor cool for someone who supposed to be a hobby collector. Of course, some people realize after spending a lot of money, that they are out money.

-
RiotCityHoods
- Hall of Fame Class of 2005

- Posts: 1115
- Joined: Sat Apr 26, 2003 3:38 pm
- Location: The 909 of Mid-Cal!
doesn't matter how deep jim's pockets are...if you wanna make (keep) friends among the collector community it is (and should be) a cardinal sin to do that.
www.circuspunks.com - Fresno Circus Punk Family! F14!
-
emhello
- RDK
- Hall of Fame Class of 2009

- Posts: 2250
- Joined: Mon Apr 28, 2003 5:54 pm
- Location: Los Angeles
emhello wrote:I doubt he'll be getting much sympathy the next time he 'needs' a rare piece in this community. IMO there is a huge line b/w being a collector and being a scalper.
*Exactly!*
I've found that most hobby's such as this one are pretty good at policing themselves. As Otto said above, you do favors and you get favors in return. You try to profit in a way that may seem underhanded to some, then you pay the consequences in, what they call in the business world, "good will." Personally, I don't seek out and buy pieces to resell. It's simply not worth my time and energy, and there's enough stuff out there that I desperately want already to waste my money on "dealing."
Given the limited facts at hand, I'm willing to take Mustang at his word that someone offered him $750 and that he decided to sell. I'd have to wonder why he bought it in the first place then, but okay. It's not something that I would do, but okay. If that isn't the case and he did just try to squeeze Jim, then that's a big no-no in my book.
Ray
-
mustangtoys
- FFJim
- HoF 2007 & CotY

- Posts: 3024
- Joined: Tue Aug 24, 2004 11:19 am
- Location: Michigan
Outbidding for your collection ... cool.
Outbidding to resell ... not so cool.
Mustang, you bought an awesome piece. Put it back on the shelf and be happy because there are only 11 others like it in the world. If you ever need the money, sell it. That's your right. On the other hand, buy and sell as you please, because that's your right too -- that's free enterprise. Just be aware that folks frown upon buy-to-sell "collectors", so you might alienate yourself if you partake in this practice. That's not good.
Dude, you scored a Naked Alex. Put him in a nice acrylic case, shine a light on him, and bask in the delight of a rare piece.
Let's all move on and play nicely together!
Outbidding to resell ... not so cool.
Mustang, you bought an awesome piece. Put it back on the shelf and be happy because there are only 11 others like it in the world. If you ever need the money, sell it. That's your right. On the other hand, buy and sell as you please, because that's your right too -- that's free enterprise. Just be aware that folks frown upon buy-to-sell "collectors", so you might alienate yourself if you partake in this practice. That's not good.
Dude, you scored a Naked Alex. Put him in a nice acrylic case, shine a light on him, and bask in the delight of a rare piece.
Let's all move on and play nicely together!
-
mustangtoys
- Krusty
- Hall of Fame Class of 2006

- Posts: 609
- Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2003 3:45 pm
mustang, look at it this way...
I get enjoyment out of hooking up friends and fellow collectors with hard to find pieces when I manage to acquire extras. I tend to either trade with them (for items that they've acquired similarly that I need), or sell to them at my exact cost. It is well within your right to sell this piece, just as it is well with the right of the eBay seller from whom you got it, but both instances reek of profiteering, and while I won't wish you any ill will, I certainly won't be doing you any favors just so you can turn around and offer to resell the piece I help you get because the profit is too irresistable.
It wasn't an accident, it was a mistake, and we are all entitled. But I'm having a hard time understanding the perspective of someone who could be so excited about winning a rare piece, paying a high price for it, and then trying to turn a quick profit on it. When a highly desirable piece comes my way, like the 3 MvsR Glows I got, the last thing on my mind is selling them, regardless of how much cash is offered to me.
One more thing... Cliff said that the id is "shared" by a child and his Dad, and you said that's correct. Who are we dealing with here, the 9 year old, or the Dad. It's tough enough relating to people in an internet forum where faces and voices are replaced by handles and "posts", but I don't think it's cool to take it one step further and overload a username so that we don't have a clue who were dealing with.
I get enjoyment out of hooking up friends and fellow collectors with hard to find pieces when I manage to acquire extras. I tend to either trade with them (for items that they've acquired similarly that I need), or sell to them at my exact cost. It is well within your right to sell this piece, just as it is well with the right of the eBay seller from whom you got it, but both instances reek of profiteering, and while I won't wish you any ill will, I certainly won't be doing you any favors just so you can turn around and offer to resell the piece I help you get because the profit is too irresistable.
It wasn't an accident, it was a mistake, and we are all entitled. But I'm having a hard time understanding the perspective of someone who could be so excited about winning a rare piece, paying a high price for it, and then trying to turn a quick profit on it. When a highly desirable piece comes my way, like the 3 MvsR Glows I got, the last thing on my mind is selling them, regardless of how much cash is offered to me.
One more thing... Cliff said that the id is "shared" by a child and his Dad, and you said that's correct. Who are we dealing with here, the 9 year old, or the Dad. It's tough enough relating to people in an internet forum where faces and voices are replaced by handles and "posts", but I don't think it's cool to take it one step further and overload a username so that we don't have a clue who were dealing with.
-
RiotCityHoods
- Hall of Fame Class of 2005

- Posts: 1115
- Joined: Sat Apr 26, 2003 3:38 pm
- Location: The 909 of Mid-Cal!
- mrcory5000
- Hall of Fame Class of 2006

- Posts: 3741
- Joined: Sun Apr 27, 2003 8:08 pm
- Location: House of 5000
- Contact:
- Krusty
- Hall of Fame Class of 2006

- Posts: 609
- Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2003 3:45 pm
mrcory5000 wrote:I think Krusty meant you both should have your very own accounts here at Funatic. Then we all would know which person we are talking to.
Yep, that's what I meant. As it is now, I'll have to assume I'm addressing either or both of you, which isn't a big deal, but is nice to know upfront. If one of your posts sounds mature, and the next day a different post sounds like a kid wrote it (I'm not saying "stupid" or "immature", just like a normal kid wrote it
), it could easily confuse people. Your online identity is forged through the content of your posts.
Look at it this way (this is addressed to the adult mustangtoys)... let's say that you kid uses this account to arrange for a trade with me. it's a reasonable trade, but not one that you would approve of. I start declining other trade offers, and send off my end of the trade. When you find out what he's done in your "shared" name, are you going to honor the trade, regardless of whether you like it? Can you not see how sharing the username could lead to problems and issues? That's all I'm saying.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot]
