Since it's become so obvious that so few were able to get the Monkey Vs. Robot glows that so many of us wanted - and because a few have already been pleading to buy a set - it's got me thinking about something.
So, say one of us here on the board was able to either acquire a second set or decided not to keep theirs (and no, I don't have a set). What would be the best way to "part" with it? Do you sell it at cost to a friend or do you offer it to the first person who responds to your post? That's obviously biased toward long time board members. Or do you Ebay it (or sell it here) to the highest bidder? In some ways that's the fairest way - let the market and desire decide - but it would likely be met with charges of opportunism. Yet if fifty people want the darn things at cost, how do you decide who is more "worthy?" He who "wants" it most or she who's willing to pay the most for it? Or do you hold a contest?
There's no correct answer, but I think it's a very valid question when it comes to limited collectibles.
M vs. R Speculation...
- RDK
- Hall of Fame Class of 2009

- Posts: 2250
- Joined: Mon Apr 28, 2003 5:54 pm
- Location: Los Angeles
-
phatjoe
- Otto13
- Hall of Fame Class of 2005

- Posts: 1908
- Joined: Thu Apr 17, 2003 1:30 am
If I had a second set...(If I only had a first set
). I "take care" of a collector who has "taken care' of me in the past. So I guess Id' send my extra set either to Fontana or Cedar Rapids or Chicago or New York or San Franscico or Cinncinati...Shoot! I'd need more than two sets! 
). I "take care" of a collector who has "taken care' of me in the past. So I guess Id' send my extra set either to Fontana or Cedar Rapids or Chicago or New York or San Franscico or Cinncinati...Shoot! I'd need more than two sets! 
New York ....................................Paris...............................Chula Vista
- swobobafett
- Hall of Fame Class of 2007

- Posts: 4480
- Joined: Sat Apr 26, 2003 12:39 pm
- Location: The Wire, MD
- Contact:
-
krinkle
Re: M vs. R Speculation...
RDK wrote:Since it's become so obvious that so few were able to get the Monkey Vs. Robot glows that so many of us wanted - and because a few have already been pleading to buy a set - it's got me thinking about something.
So, say one of us here on the board was able to either acquire a second set or decided not to keep theirs (and no, I don't have a set). What would be the best way to "part" with it? Do you sell it at cost to a friend or do you offer it to the first person who responds to your post? That's obviously biased toward long time board members. Or do you Ebay it (or sell it here) to the highest bidder? In some ways that's the fairest way - let the market and desire decide - but it would likely be met with charges of opportunism. Yet if fifty people want the darn things at cost, how do you decide who is more "worthy?" He who "wants" it most or she who's willing to pay the most for it? Or do you hold a contest?
There's no correct answer, but I think it's a very valid question when it comes to limited collectibles.
That is an interesting question. Otto has a good point.
But as someone who is relatively new, but dedicated to the SP line I would prefer eBay. But I did think of another way that I would consider fair. A contest where the winner would be aloud to buy the peices for a set price specified at the begining of the contest. In a case like this I would ask the board for guidence on pricing, but I do not think it would be unresonable to ask for some amount above cost. And the holder of the items/contest could completely disregard the advice a well. At the very least the seller is giving us Funatics a first chance at the items. Dunno, if the abive seems any fairer than any otehr method, but alas I want me some MVSR Glows!

- Franko 5621
- Posts: 149
- Joined: Tue Jun 24, 2003 6:28 pm
- Location: Greensboro, NC USA
- ltjpezkid
- Hall of Fame Class of 2006

- Posts: 2104
- Joined: Mon Oct 18, 2004 3:54 pm
- Location: Orillia Ontario
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users
