Damaged Pop Boxes
Forum rules
This section is for general Pop discussion, not showing off your recent acquisitions. Please use the Dance Hall for collection addition pictures.
Please post Funko subscription box and item discussions in the Powered By Funko section.
This section is for general Pop discussion, not showing off your recent acquisitions. Please use the Dance Hall for collection addition pictures.
Please post Funko subscription box and item discussions in the Powered By Funko section.
- Kenjutsu763
- Posts: 496
- Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2017 8:59 am
- Location: Minnesota
Damaged Pop Boxes
The other day I was out funting for some Stranger Things pops, and found myself looking at ever single angle and aspect of the boxes before finally choosing one that had no damage on it.
Being that there are so many in box collectors, do you think retailers should be taking box damage into account when selling the item? Should the damaged boxes be damaged out or sold for discount?
I've been told time and again that since the actual item inside is not damaged, no discount can really be applied. While I can understand this as a normal consumer, as a collector, the value drops significantly. This is not to say that I look for damaged items in order to get a discount, but I am more inclined to purchased a flawless box over one that's been run through with a boxcutter.
Being that there are so many in box collectors, do you think retailers should be taking box damage into account when selling the item? Should the damaged boxes be damaged out or sold for discount?
I've been told time and again that since the actual item inside is not damaged, no discount can really be applied. While I can understand this as a normal consumer, as a collector, the value drops significantly. This is not to say that I look for damaged items in order to get a discount, but I am more inclined to purchased a flawless box over one that's been run through with a boxcutter.
"You're overwhelmed. Freeze was underwhelmed. Why isn't anyone ever just whelmed?"- Dick Grayson, Young Justice 1x01
Collection: Ask, and I'll send a link
ISO: Monk Tang(Gold)

Signature from soliquenl https://soliquenl.deviantart.com/
Collection: Ask, and I'll send a link

ISO: Monk Tang(Gold)

Signature from soliquenl https://soliquenl.deviantart.com/
- Valde
- HOF 2022 & CotM

- Posts: 5379
- Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2014 4:43 pm
- Location: Las Vegas
- Contact:
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
I don’t think retailers should care how boxes look, regardless of what collectors want. There is no way to control how boxes get treated while they travel thousands of miles from Everett to the retail shipping center for HT/GS/Target then to the actual store, then employees placing them on the shelf. I’m kind of surprised when boxes don’t have minor damage to them, like a ding from someone nail or whatever. If every retail store sold damaged boxes for less each store could lose thousands of dollars a month creating a massive loss based on what a fraction of their customer base wants. They count discount them but it might result in them just increasing the price on mint boxes.
Grail: Super Freddy
Jason - va1de on Instagram



Jason - va1de on Instagram



- ethaneee22
- Posts: 139
- Joined: Sat May 16, 2015 10:14 pm
- Location: Florida
- Contact:
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
From a collectors point of view I agree that it would make sense for them to be discounted slightly.
But from their perspective, these are just toys and they probably think children buy them and rip the boxes open.
I guess it would be like if someone asked for a discount on an xbox because the corner of the box was damaged, but if the xbox itself has no damage then it would make no sense for them to lose money because someone wanted a pristine box.
But I guess it depends on the retailer and how damaged the box is. Ive seen some stores like hot topic give discounts on damaged boxes and the disney treasure boxes that has items missing.
But from their perspective, these are just toys and they probably think children buy them and rip the boxes open.
I guess it would be like if someone asked for a discount on an xbox because the corner of the box was damaged, but if the xbox itself has no damage then it would make no sense for them to lose money because someone wanted a pristine box.
But I guess it depends on the retailer and how damaged the box is. Ive seen some stores like hot topic give discounts on damaged boxes and the disney treasure boxes that has items missing.

- JohnnyPOP
- Posts: 4830
- Joined: Wed Mar 02, 2016 10:22 am
- Location: Texas
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
It's so easy for these boxes to get damaged during the shipping process alone. To damage out all of the ones with even a slight crease or flaw, we'd have only a handful to put out on the floor. I work in the backroom of my store and I receive everything and we get bent boxes in all the time. I understand people want perfect boxes but it's not fair to retailers to expect that everytime.
Discounts will vary from store to store anyway, and not every collector is an in box collector. When we get in our exclusives, I do my best to ensure the boxes for the customer holds are as good as I can find but that's only because I know how picky people can be.
Discounts will vary from store to store anyway, and not every collector is an in box collector. When we get in our exclusives, I do my best to ensure the boxes for the customer holds are as good as I can find but that's only because I know how picky people can be.

- datfunkojawn
- Posts: 384
- Joined: Mon Jul 25, 2016 11:35 pm
- Location: Philadelphia, PA
- Contact:
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
Giant retailers don’t care. They prob buy these for dirt cheap and even while thrown in the clearance bin they’re still making profit regardless of condition of the boxes. Sure retailers want to sell you great mint items but it’s not up to them once it hits the shelves and hundreds of people are touching and handling the boxes. Too them this is small change (small profits) in the ocean of other products they sell at the stores. So to them it’s why spend all that time focus on small change item when other items we sell bring in larger profits.
Doesn’t hurt to ask for a discount though if you do find a busted box. Worst case scenario is a no. No harm no foul.
Doesn’t hurt to ask for a discount though if you do find a busted box. Worst case scenario is a no. No harm no foul.
Collecting since March '16 - Philadelphia, PA - My Motto: "Buy it NOW, Regret it LATER"
IG: datfunkojawn



IG: datfunkojawn



-
PoP305
- Posts: 314
- Joined: Fri Jun 09, 2017 4:47 pm
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
No,the actual product is the PoP,not the box.
-
Lakers
- Posts: 1146
- Joined: Sat Aug 05, 2017 7:09 pm
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
I would like if someone have a thread about how can fix minor damages in the box.
- CaseyJones14
- HOF 2022 & CotM & CotY

- Posts: 10409
- Joined: Wed May 11, 2016 12:32 pm
- Location: Dorbztown, USA
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
PoP305 wrote:No,the actual product is the PoP,not the box.
This. I wonder if in box collectors would rather have a perfect box that has a Pop missing an arm or has a huge paint defect over a pristine Pop with a little dent on the back of the box.

Brett - caseyj0nes14 on Instagram
ISO - Dorbz and McNugget Protos!
- Kenjutsu763
- Posts: 496
- Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2017 8:59 am
- Location: Minnesota
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
CaseyJones14 wrote:PoP305 wrote:No,the actual product is the PoP,not the box.
This. I wonder if in box collectors would rather have a perfect box that has a Pop missing an arm or has a huge paint defect over a pristine Pop with a little dent on the back of the box.
Honestly, it depends for me. I prefer to have a pristine box. If I see a common on the shelf and the box is smashed in any way, I consider walking away and hoping to find it elsewhere. If it's a more expensive pop that I can get for less because the box is jacked, I'll pick that up. If the pop itself is defective, I find that to be an interesting quirk and might pick it up anyway. This doesn't apply to broken ones though.
I disagree that the pop is the product and not the box though. Both of the items are part of the box. Yes, kids can buy them and play with them, but for the most part, these were designed as collector items. If not, why would we have limit count productions or pops that are incapable of standing on their own outside fo the box?
"You're overwhelmed. Freeze was underwhelmed. Why isn't anyone ever just whelmed?"- Dick Grayson, Young Justice 1x01
Collection: Ask, and I'll send a link
ISO: Monk Tang(Gold)

Signature from soliquenl https://soliquenl.deviantart.com/
Collection: Ask, and I'll send a link

ISO: Monk Tang(Gold)

Signature from soliquenl https://soliquenl.deviantart.com/
- CaseyJones14
- HOF 2022 & CotM & CotY

- Posts: 10409
- Joined: Wed May 11, 2016 12:32 pm
- Location: Dorbztown, USA
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
Kenjutsu763 wrote:I disagree that the pop is the product and not the box though. Both of the items are part of the box. Yes, kids can buy them and play with them, but for the most part, these were designed as collector items. If not, why would we have limit count productions or pops that are incapable of standing on their own outside fo the box?
The great thing about collecting is there is no wrong or right way to do it. Funko always says that Pops were meant to come out of the box, but that doesn't mean everybody will do that. And you bring up Pops being incapable of standing outside the box - why does Funko include stands for Pops if they aren't meant to be taken out
I know this topic has been beaten to death and I respect both sides, but it is interesting seeing different points of view. I take everything out including LE 24 items, but that's because I never intend on selling and in my mind they are priceless


Brett - caseyj0nes14 on Instagram
ISO - Dorbz and McNugget Protos!
-
MzTredecim
- Posts: 276
- Joined: Sat Sep 24, 2016 11:10 am
- Contact:
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
Lakers wrote:I would like if someone have a thread about how can fix minor damages in the box.
What kind of damage are you talking about? I've ended up with some rather beat up boxes over the years and had some luck fixing some internal creases and box bulging with an iron. Its the same technique used for usual cardboard repair like old school video game boxes and board games. Just don't touch the iron to the plastic window. Deep creases can be straightened out but there will still be a visible line. Moreso for tears and holes.
Funko Collector since 2012!
Collections: GITD / TWD / TMNTs / BTTF / Random Eye-Catchers / Mystery Minis & PSHs
Collections: GITD / TWD / TMNTs / BTTF / Random Eye-Catchers / Mystery Minis & PSHs
-
MzTredecim
- Posts: 276
- Joined: Sat Sep 24, 2016 11:10 am
- Contact:
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
CaseyJones14 wrote:PoP305 wrote:No,the actual product is the PoP,not the box.
This. I wonder if in box collectors would rather have a perfect box that has a Pop missing an arm or has a huge paint defect over a pristine Pop with a little dent on the back of the box.
I much prefer a good figure with a good paint job over a mint box. That said though, I am mainly an IB collector due to how much space I'm allowing for pops since I have other collections. I have found myself passing on pops that I wanted due to the boxes being beaten up. It probably depends on how difficult I think the pop will be to find again and how much I really want it. I would frequently find out just how bad I really wanted a pop at Walmart and TRU.
Funko Collector since 2012!
Collections: GITD / TWD / TMNTs / BTTF / Random Eye-Catchers / Mystery Minis & PSHs
Collections: GITD / TWD / TMNTs / BTTF / Random Eye-Catchers / Mystery Minis & PSHs
- katersatz
- Posts: 417
- Joined: Fri May 25, 2018 4:38 pm
- Location: Canada
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
I find there is a certain satisfaction in cleaning up or repairing a box (or Pop) that isn't mint..something that adds to my appreciation for it in my collection. That being said, I have caught myself focusing too much on choosing the BEST box and overlooking a big flaw with the figure itself...which feels pretty stupid.
The hunt for a perfect box can be silly and overblown but it can also add to the fun. Like anything with collecting, it should be fun...otherwise why do it.
The hunt for a perfect box can be silly and overblown but it can also add to the fun. Like anything with collecting, it should be fun...otherwise why do it.
"Everyone's a fan of...too many things."




- coopscohen
- Posts: 1373
- Joined: Fri May 19, 2017 2:13 am
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
Kenjutsu763 wrote:This is not to say that I look for damaged items in order to get a discount, but I am more inclined to purchased a flawless box over one that's been run through with a boxcutter.
It amazes me the amount of pops I do come across with a boxcutter line on the top. You would think employees would know how to open the shipper box but I’m sure some don’t care.


- MONSTER
- Posts: 1030
- Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2016 11:22 pm
- Location: Southern California
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
dented, dinged and crush boxes are going to happen. It's just part of collecting. Stores aren't going to give discounts for it.
Last edited by MONSTER on Sun Aug 05, 2018 1:49 pm, edited 1 time in total.

-
MzTredecim
- Posts: 276
- Joined: Sat Sep 24, 2016 11:10 am
- Contact:
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
coopscohen wrote:Kenjutsu763 wrote:This is not to say that I look for damaged items in order to get a discount, but I am more inclined to purchased a flawless box over one that's been run through with a boxcutter.
It amazes me the amount of pops I do come across with a boxcutter line on the top. You would think employees would know how to open the shipper box but I’m sure some don’t care.
I've found the box cutter line to be a real problem with the larger pop boxes. Even been standing from of the employee when they've cut it. Usually they are just in a hurry and box cuts aren't a real issue with most other products.
Funko Collector since 2012!
Collections: GITD / TWD / TMNTs / BTTF / Random Eye-Catchers / Mystery Minis & PSHs
Collections: GITD / TWD / TMNTs / BTTF / Random Eye-Catchers / Mystery Minis & PSHs
- Kenjutsu763
- Posts: 496
- Joined: Tue Jul 25, 2017 8:59 am
- Location: Minnesota
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
CaseyJones14 wrote:Kenjutsu763 wrote:I disagree that the pop is the product and not the box though. Both of the items are part of the box. Yes, kids can buy them and play with them, but for the most part, these were designed as collector items. If not, why would we have limit count productions or pops that are incapable of standing on their own outside fo the box?
The great thing about collecting is there is no wrong or right way to do it. Funko always says that Pops were meant to come out of the box, but that doesn't mean everybody will do that. And you bring up Pops being incapable of standing outside the box - why does Funko include stands for Pops if they aren't meant to be taken out![]()
I know this topic has been beaten to death and I respect both sides, but it is interesting seeing different points of view. I take everything out including LE 24 items, but that's because I never intend on selling and in my mind they are priceless
That's a good point. I forgot about the ones that come with stands.
I also don't itend on selling or trading any of mine. That's also why I don't do pick ups for people unless I know they're actually keeping the pop instead of trying to net some value.
"You're overwhelmed. Freeze was underwhelmed. Why isn't anyone ever just whelmed?"- Dick Grayson, Young Justice 1x01
Collection: Ask, and I'll send a link
ISO: Monk Tang(Gold)

Signature from soliquenl https://soliquenl.deviantart.com/
Collection: Ask, and I'll send a link

ISO: Monk Tang(Gold)

Signature from soliquenl https://soliquenl.deviantart.com/
- abefarley
- Posts: 90
- Joined: Wed Aug 01, 2018 4:06 pm
- Location: Daphne, AL
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
The pain and panic i ordered from the pop up shop came with a jacked up box...the actual box the items shipped in was pretty smashed. Funko said that since the items werent messed up, then they cant replace them. I completely understand but it still kinda sucks for those of us who want to display them in the box.
- Cephus
- Posts: 321
- Joined: Sun Aug 13, 2017 4:36 pm
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
If you don't like the box, don't buy it. I have walked out of stores empty handed because they had nothing I would pay for. I have returned Pops that have shown up damaged. I don't care if the store likes it, it's my money, I will spend it how and where I want. Just be prepared, if you can't find a box in the condition you want, not to get the Pop at all. It's a trade off.
- angrykoalagear
- Posts: 907
- Joined: Sat May 31, 2014 5:00 pm
- Location: Tucson, AZ
- Contact:
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
If retailers were to have to worry about the condition of a box, could you imagine how long it would take for transactions to take place or how long these lines would be for sticklers. Stores would have to keep them behind their counters just to make sure no one touches the boxes and they do not have any time for that. I guess the best way to guarantee a somewhat perfect box is to start going wholesale and buying cases.
- JJLecaros
- Posts: 1679
- Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2016 4:48 pm
- Location: Bay Area
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
my LCS takes box damage into account if its a pricer pop if its common they sell it for regular price.

- Shalee04
- Posts: 3072
- Joined: Fri Jun 03, 2016 2:18 pm
- Location: Bakersfield,Calif
- Contact:
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
We have both types of collectors in my family.
Me and 1 kid are OOB collectors
Hubby and the other kid are in box collectors.
Our oldest kid, is a collected proffesor and thinks we are all crazy Funko hoarders. Hahaha
Me and 1 kid are OOB collectors
Hubby and the other kid are in box collectors.
Our oldest kid, is a collected proffesor and thinks we are all crazy Funko hoarders. Hahaha
They call me Kelly
OOB deals I love to find.
Disney is my first love whether it be pops, Dorbz , minis or dolls.
Pops and Dorbz -2000+~~~ I have lost count actually
Minis-450+
Protos-2 Dug with cone from my first fundays in 2016
And
Baby Groot with bomb from 2018

OOB deals I love to find.
Disney is my first love whether it be pops, Dorbz , minis or dolls.
Pops and Dorbz -2000+~~~ I have lost count actually
Minis-450+
Protos-2 Dug with cone from my first fundays in 2016
And
Baby Groot with bomb from 2018

- codytranum
- Posts: 637
- Joined: Fri Mar 30, 2018 9:52 pm
- Location: France
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
I've been trying to stop caring so much about dings and dents on boxes. It becomes more and more stressful and frustrating to try to always find a perfect condition box out on the floor, or order one online and not have it destroyed by the delivery service, etc. Especially because, as others have said, if the store discounted every pop with some minor bent cardboard they'd only have a small handful they'd be able to price full price. Personally I just don't think it's worth the headache to be meticulous about it.
- ugagerman
- Posts: 255
- Joined: Wed Jan 17, 2018 10:26 pm
- Location: California
Re: Damaged Pop Boxes
It's always annoying finding the perfect box but the pop itself having paint flaws.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Baidu [Spider]
